Pasta saucesVegetarianGluten-free

Classic Tomato Sauce

Whole plum tomatoes simmered slowly with butter and a halved onion: a famously simple, silky sauce.

makes 43 cubes, about 7p each

Illustration of a bowl of Classic Tomato Sauce
Time
55 min5 min prep · 50 min cook (45 min hands-off)
Makes
43 cubes
Cost per cubePer cube
7pabout £3.01 a batch · 28p a serving
Calories per cubeCalories
33 kcal
A serving
4 cubes
Spice

Sweet, round and buttery, with the onion giving a gentle background flavour before it's lifted out. Whole plum tomatoes are crushed by hand and left at a slow simmer for 45 minutes until thick and the butter floats free, then blended smooth or left as they are. Cubes go straight into a pan with a splash of water and are ready in about 5 minutes.

Ingredients

Batch size
  • 4 × 400g tinswhole plum tomatoes
  • 140gunsalted butter
  • 2 (300g)onions, peeled and halved
  • 6gsalt

Allergens: Milk. Check the labels on stock cubes, sauces and pastes, as brands vary.

Method

  1. Step 1: Tip the tomatoes and their juice into a wide saucepan and crush them roughly with your hand or a potato masher.
  2. Step 2: Add the butter, the halved onions and the salt.
  3. Step 3: Bring to a simmer, then cook uncovered at a slow, steady simmer for 45 minutes, crushing the tomatoes now and then, until thick and the butter floats free.
  4. Step 4: Lift out the onions (they make a lovely cook's snack). Taste for salt, and blend smooth if you prefer.
  5. Step 5: Cool, pour into 30ml ice-cube trays and freeze.
Nutrition (estimated)
kcalproteincarbsfatfibresalt
Per cube330.4g1.4g2.7g0.3g0.19g
Per 4 cubes1321.6g5.6g10.8g1.2g0.76g

Cook’s notes

  • Good tinned plum tomatoes are most of the flavour, so buy the best you can.

Use it for

  • Spaghetti with parmesan for one · 4 cubes
  • Pizza base topping · 2 cubes
  • Meatballs or chicken simmered in sauce · 6 cubes

Freeze, reheat and serve

Freeze
Cool it within two hours, freeze it in 30ml ice-cube trays, then bag and label the cubes. It keeps for 4 months.
Use from frozen
Drop straight into a pan from frozen with a splash of water; ready in 5 minutes. Never refreeze thawed cubes.
A portion
4 cubes is a serving: about 132 kcal.

Classic Tomato Sauce questions

Can I make it dairy-free?

Use olive oil instead of the butter. The sauce will taste fruitier and a little less silky, but it's still very good.

Can I use chopped tomatoes instead of whole?

You can, though whole plum tomatoes tend to be better quality and cook down into a sweeter, silkier sauce. With chopped tomatoes there's no need to crush them.

Why are the onions only halved?

Halved onions give the sauce a gentle sweetness without any chopped bits, and they're easy to lift out at the end. That keeps the sauce smooth even if you don't blend it.

In collections
More like this

Updated . Nutrition, costs and yields are estimates.

Cooking Classic Tomato Sauce